SNAP participation has fallen by more than 4.5 million people — including over 1.5 million children — as states preemptively restrict access ahead of the Republican reconciliation law’s cost-sharing requirement, set to begin in fall 2027, according to a report published Tuesday by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities analyzing newly released USDA data.
The paradox at the center of the report is stark: the cost-sharing policy has not formally taken effect, yet its impact is already measurable in every state but Alaska. Forty-four states have seen participation fall by 5 percent or more, and 23 have experienced drops exceeding 10 percent. CBPP found that 35 states and one U.S. territory will face substantial new costs to continue participating in SNAP beginning October 2027, with the total state cost shift estimated at roughly $9 billion in fiscal year 2028 alone. Nearly half of those states could owe $100 million or more.
Under the reconciliation law enacted in July 2025, states with SNAP payment error rates above 6 percent must cover 5 to 15 percent of benefit costs — a structural break from a program that has been entirely federally funded since its creation more than 50 years ago. States with error rates above 13.33 percent received a last-minute carve-out granting a one- or two-year implementation delay. That threshold, CBPP argued, “unfairly penalizes states with better accuracy.” New Jersey, for example, reduced its error rate by more than 7 percentage points — the largest improvement of any state — dropping it from 14.33 percent to 6.86 percent. As a result, New Jersey now faces an estimated $100 million annual cost-sharing obligation because its rate fell below the delay threshold, effectively punishing the state for its improvement.
The decline in enrollment already exceeds Congressional Budget Office projections, which estimated the law would reduce monthly participation by 2.4 million. Stateline reported that the National Association of State Budget Officers projected the combined state costs for SNAP administration and benefits under the law are comparable to total state transportation spending in fiscal year 2025 — a figure that underscores the fiscal scale of the shift.
Arizona illustrates the most extreme case. The state’s SNAP participation dropped more than 50 percent in the first 10 months after enactment, after Arizona substantially ramped up documentation requirements while simultaneously laying off hundreds of eligibility workers. Applicants reported being denied benefits for failing to provide signed statements verifying household composition, even when there was no reason to question the information they had submitted.
CBPP warned that SNAP rules create a perverse incentive structure: issuing benefits to an eligible family at the wrong amount increases a state’s error rate and cost-sharing penalty, but denying benefits to eligible households does not count as an error. States facing massive new fiscal exposure are responding predictably — shortened certification periods, additional paperwork requirements, and in-person office visits that fall hardest on seniors, people with disabilities, and working families.
USDA has issued no guidance on how the cost shift will be operationalized, and the administration’s regulatory agenda indicates proposed rules will not arrive until December or later — long after most states must finalize their fiscal year 2028 budgets. CBPP called on Congress to delay the cost-sharing requirement for all states and to postpone the reconciliation law’s 50 percent cut to federal administrative reimbursement. Without intervention, the organization warned, some states may be forced to withdraw from SNAP entirely — eliminating food assistance in states that have participated in the program since 1974.