House Panel Calls Medical Residency Match System an Illegal Monopoly

House Judiciary Committee report alleges the National Resident Matching Program operates as an illegal hiring monopoly, harming doctors, patients, and rural healthcare access.

The House Judiciary Committee on Thursday released an interim staff report alleging that the National Resident Matching Program operates as an illegal hiring monopoly that suppresses physician wages, limits career mobility and restricts competition in the medical residency system.

The report, titled “Medical Mis-Match: How a Residency Hiring Monopoly Harms Patients, Doctors, and the American Public,” examines the residency matching system as physician workforce shortages continue across the United States.

The National Resident Matching Program, commonly known as “the Match,” has overseen residency placement for more than 70 years. After graduating from medical school, physicians must complete a supervised residency lasting three to seven years before they can practice independently.

Under the system, applicants and residency programs submit confidential rank-order lists, and an algorithm creates binding matches. According to the committee, applicants cannot negotiate salaries, compare competing offers or decline a match without affecting their eligibility for future matches.

According to the report, the committee reviewed 1,580 documents from five medical organizations and four teaching hospitals, along with interviews with physicians. The report states that the Match expanded its role through an “All In” policy adopted in 2013 requiring participating programs to fill all residency positions through the system.

It also notes that the program later merged with National Matching Services, which had been used by osteopathic residency applicants, resulting in nearly all U.S. residency positions being filled through a single system by 2020.

The report cites financial data showing first-year residents earned an average salary of $66,712 in 2024, while licensed physicians earned an average of $374,000. It also states that nurse practitioners earned a median salary of $132,050 and that about 75% of medical school graduates enter residency with an average of $190,000 in student loan debt. According to the committee, the salary range for first-year residents varies by about $9,000 across institutions.

The report notes that Congress granted the Match an exemption from federal antitrust lawsuits through a provision included in the Pension Funding Equity Act of 2004. According to the committee, the exemption followed lobbying efforts by the Association of American Medical Colleges and the American Hospital Association.

The committee also cited testimony from Thomas P. Miller of the American Enterprise Institute before the House Judiciary Committee’s antitrust subcommittee. Miller told lawmakers that Congress should consider limiting or repealing the antitrust exemption.

The committee said it will continue its oversight as it considers potential legislative changes. Rep. Victoria Spartz has reintroduced the Restoring Rights of Medical Residents Act (H.R. 3018), which would repeal the antitrust exemption and allow courts to review whether the Match complies with federal competition law.

According to the committee, the legislation would not eliminate the residency matching system but would remove its statutory protection from antitrust challenges.

Washington Signal Reports

No author description yet …

Related Coverage

Advertisement · 300×250

Get the weekly Signal.

Congress, industry, and local — fully briefed.

Most Read

Advertisement · 300×250