President Donald Trump on Thursday fired the two remaining Democratic commissioners of the U.S. Election Assistance Commission, and the lone Republican commissioner subsequently resigned, leaving the only federal agency devoted solely to election administration entirely without leadership less than four months before the 2026 midterm elections.
The departures create an immediate functional crisis at the EAC. Without commissioners, the agency cannot certify new voting systems, issue updated election administration guidelines, or make policy decisions about the distribution of election security grants to states — all core functions during a period when state and local officials are finalizing preparations for November.
Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA), Ranking Member of the Senate Rules Committee, and Rep. Joe Morelle (D-NY) called the firings “illegal” in a joint statement released Wednesday, accusing the president of “trying to dismantle yet another independent guardrail of our democracy designed to keep elections fair and secure.” Padilla charged that the purge was “a blatant part of his plan to politicize our elections and enable more unlawful and dangerous election interference.”
Democratic commissioners Thomas Hicks and Benjamin Hovland were notified by email that their positions were “terminated, effective immediately,” according to Votebeat, which first reported the ousters. Republican commissioner Christy McCormick was allowed to resign, according to three sources within the agency who spoke to Votebeat. A fourth commissioner, Republican Donald Palmer, had voluntarily departed the agency earlier this year to join the Heritage Foundation.
The EAC was created by the Help America Vote Act of 2002 in the aftermath of the disputed 2000 presidential election, which established it as an evenly divided, four-member commission — no more than two of any one political party. Under HAVA, commissioners are appointed by the president, confirmed by the Senate, and serve until their successors take office. Padilla argued the firings violated this statutory holdover provision.
The White House defended the move, citing the Supreme Court’s late-June decision in Trump v. Slaughter, which rolled back 90 years of precedent preventing at-will removal of independent agency officials. A White House official told ABC News that the president “reserves the right to remove individuals that may not be totally aligned with the important task of securing America’s elections and ensuring every legal vote is counted.”
Hovland, in a phone interview with ABC News on Friday, said the firings would lead to “less support, and probably less confidence” in U.S. elections. “We’ve arrived at a time where elections are harder than they’ve ever been to run, the people who run them are stretched thin, and now there are three less people working to support those public servants,” he said.
The Slaughter decision — in which the court’s 6-3 conservative majority upheld Trump’s authority to fire Federal Trade Commission member Louise Slaughter — has given the administration a legal foothold for removing officials across a range of independent agencies. Whether that precedent extends to the EAC’s specific statutory structure under HAVA remains untested in court. The EAC had previously declined to implement part of a Trump executive order requiring proof of citizenship on the national mail voter registration form, a decision that may have contributed to the administration’s interest in reconstituting the commission.
Whether any fired commissioner will challenge the termination legally is unclear. If one does, the case could test the outer boundaries of the Slaughter ruling and determine whether Congress can insulate independent election oversight from presidential control.